The square metre rate

The most common yardstick for building cost is the rate per square metre: the net cost of the building, excluding site works and land, divided by its gross floor area. Gross floor area is measured inside the external walls.

The rate is useful for cost planning, but only if you compare like with like. Before setting one project's rate against another's, adjust for differences in site, specification, timing and contract conditions.

Shape on plan

Simple shapes generally cost less per square metre than complex ones. An irregular plan with projections and set-backs needs more external wall for the same floor area, and it complicates almost every trade: setting out, excavation, drainage, brickwork and the roof.

Even among regular shapes, cost rises as the plan gets longer and narrower. Take a 400 m² single-storey building with 3 m high external walls:

  • As a 20 m × 20 m square it needs 80 m of external wall.
  • As a 100 m × 4 m rectangle it needs 208 m of external wall.

At an illustrative walling rate of R200/m², the walls of the square cost R120 per square metre of floor and those of the rectangle R312. That is R76 800 more for the same floor area.

Shape is not always free to choose. The building's function (a factory, school, hospital or hotel), the slope and shape of the site, and the depth of space tenants want all have a say.

Size

Larger buildings usually cost less per square metre. Preliminaries and general items such as site supervision and establishment do not grow in step with the building, so they make up a smaller share of a bigger contract. Larger projects also benefit from bulk buying of materials and from larger, simpler rooms.

Fullness on plan

A plan with many internal walls, bathrooms and small rooms packed into its area costs more per square metre than an open one. Two blocks of the same size can differ sharply in rate simply because one has more partitions and wet areas than the other.

Wall-to-floor ratio

The wall-to-floor ratio is the area of the enclosing walls divided by the floor area. The lower the ratio, the more economical the plan. It matters because the external envelope can account for 20 to 30% of a building's cost, and an external wall costs roughly twice as much as an internal partition.

A circle gives the lowest ratio of all, but curved construction is expensive enough to cancel the saving. A sensible step is to set a target ratio in the design brief, based on earlier projects of the same type.

Try it on your own plan

Enter the outside dimensions of a rectangular single-storey plan.

Floor area
–
Length of external wall
–
External wall area
–
Wall-to-floor ratio
–

Circulation space

Entrance halls, passages, stairs and lift shafts earn no rent, but they still have to be built, lit, cleaned, air-conditioned and maintained. In one comparison of blocks of flats, circulation ranged from 22% to 32% of the total floor area. As with the wall-to-floor ratio, the brief should set a target for circulation space based on past projects.

Height and other factors

  • Storey height. Taller floor-to-ceiling heights mean more wall, cladding and services per square metre of floor.
  • Building height. Building up rather than out can save on roof and foundations, but beyond a point the cost of lifts, structure, services and substructure outweighs the saving. Land value and plot size often decide the matter.
  • Construction method. Concrete frame or loadbearing brick, industrialised or conventional building: the choice has a large effect on cost and should be made with the quantity surveyor involved.
  • Finishes and detailing. The standard of finishes, especially on walls, is easy to underestimate and hard to compare from one project to the next.
  • Programme. Finishing earlier saves money, but only with proper planning. Inviting contractors to tender on both price and time can reward realistic, shorter programmes.
  • Contract type. A full bill of quantities gives the most reliable tender comparison, but there are many other contract forms, from cost-plus and target cost to package deals. Decide on the procurement route at sketch design stage.
  • Locality and market. Costs vary across the country and even within a city, for example on high-security sites where labour and working hours are restricted. In a slow market, competition sharpens tender prices.

What this means for you

Small design changes can have large cost effects, and cost, appearance and function have to be balanced together. The architect designs; the quantity surveyor monitors cost; but it is the client who must set the parameters at the start.

  • Involve a quantity surveyor at sketch design stage, not only when the drawings are finished.
  • Put cost targets in the brief: a budget, a wall-to-floor ratio and a share of circulation space.
  • Ask for an elemental cost plan, so every part of the building has its own target and design changes can be checked against it.
  • Choose the procurement route early.
  • Think beyond the building contract: maintenance and running costs over the life of the building matter too.

The rand figures on this page are historical examples that illustrate the principles. They are not current rates. For advice on your own project, talk to us.

This page is based on The Influence of Design on Building Cost, written by Bert van den Heever for the ASAQS and published in the ASAQS resource library.